CYC-Net

CYC-Net on Facebook CYC-Net on Twitter Search CYC-Net

Join Our Mailing List

CYC-Online
87 APRIL 2006
ListenListen to this

staff relationships

“Romance” and child care workers

Hy Resnick

Child care staff, to be effective, need to develop close professional relationships with each other as they work with the kids in their agencies. The nature of their work, and the emotionally charged interactions of much of their work can create conditions in which these work relationships develop into romantic relationships. Despite advice from friends, supervisors, colleagues and sometimes explicit contractual statements warning against such relationships – they do happen. When workers become intimately involved it can be problematic not only for the two persons involved but for the agency and the kids as well.

When the persons involved are of the same level or status in the agency the problem can sometimes be managed, but when these relationships occur between a supervisor and a supervisee it can be much more risky and troublesome – a power differential is present which increases the potential of problems occurring – four of which are discussed below:

1. Favoritism
When the child care worker in this relationship is given opportunities or rewards co-workers might see these 'goodies' going to those workers who have special relationships with the 'boss' and not their work competence. When this happens the organizational norm that hard work and competence will yield appropriate rewards (pay raises, juicy assignments, promotions, etc) becomes contaminated. Co-workers have reason to see this situation as harmful to their interests as workers.

2. Kids sensing the relationship
It's difficult if not impossible for these 'secret' relationships to go unnoticed and soon the kids also get wind of what's going on between the two and will find ways to manipulate this situation for unhealthy ends. Especially if the kids observe intimate behaviors taking place in the work environment this will feed into their fantasies about one or the other worker in an untherapeutic way and can cause relationships with either partner (or both) to be confused and tainted. In a therapeutic camp for boys, when one of the campers thought he discovered one of his female counselors dating her male supervisor he become upset and physically attacked both of them!

3. If the relationship ends
Its probably easier to begin a romantic relationship in a work setting than it is to end one especially if both partners remain in the same unit or department. However these relationships do end sometimes and life for both partners can become quite messy as every assignment or evaluation or pay raise, etc., becomes a subject for gossip and questioning. Especially is this true if the relationship ended badly with much rancor and bitterness. In this case the objectivity needed in effective supervisor-supervisee relationships is adversely affected and will make continued working together difficult if not impossible. Competent staff may have to leave or at leas t be transferred to other sectors of the agency causing disruption in the agency and no doubt hurt feelings amongst the two.

4. Communication
When these relationships develop other staff members soon sense there is something different in the interaction between the two (hard to hide anything this 'juicy' in a small agency) and a gossip culture kicks in. Communication in this culture increasingly is about this personal relationship and its impact on the agency and rarely is this secret relationship acknowledged or dealt with openly – nor can it be, and so communication in the agency becomes less and less open – not a good thing for therapeutic work with troubled young people.

However problematic such relationships are they will happen. But they will have the least chance of doing damage if the following conditions can be met:

If both parties:

For those readers who are in such relationships or who are contemplating same the above suggests that they think long and hard about this issue before jumping in or staying in this kind of relationship. The problem of course is that very few of us have choice about whom we find attractive. But we can choose whom to date and we can try to avoid situations like those described above that promise pain for you and others.

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

P.O. Box 23199, Claremont 7735, Cape Town, South Africa | P.O. Box 21464, MacDonald Drive, St. John's, NL A1A 5G6, Canada

Board of Governors | Constitution | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App