Editors' Note: For those who must
work with larger and/or difficult groups, for instance in youth
justice or secure environments, and where order and predictability
are necessary to a program, we are reminded that simple, practical
and time-honoured methods of management are helpful. This document
was compiled twenty or more years ago by Masud Hoghughi. The program
concerned is not named.
Child Management
1. Line Ups
Lining up children is a helpful group management technique.
It is particularly useful before moving children from one situation
to another. The benefits are:
(a) Sets a tone of order before departure;
(b) Aids distribution of children to escorts;
(c) Allows staff to state expectations clearly;
(d) Aids reception of expectations by children;
(e) Easy head count.
2. Calling Together
Calling children together at any time can defuse/resolve
difficult situations. Quite simply if any aspect of individual or
group behaviour is of concern to staff the group can be called
together and presented with this concern. It is often the case that
children are reassured when they know that staff are aware of
emerging situations and will often compensate or self control when
given the opportunity.
3. Phase Completion
In this place it is often the case that by nature of the
intake and resources that daily life is hectic, and staff are
subject to massive demands, often as a result of requests from
children.
In such a situation staff can be bustled/rushed into decisions or
action. This can leave them flustered. Phase completion reduces this
possibility. Simply put, ‘phase completion’ means completing one
task before embarking on the next. This particularly applies to
early morning routines. The message to children is: “When we’ve done
this — we’ll do that”.
4. Setting Expectations
Setting expectations is simply laying down prerequisite
guidelines to children. This can usefully be employed for meal times
and activities but can be central to the management of children in
any situation. Examples might be:
“I want you to sit at the table quietly”.
“When we return to the house I want people to hang their towels on
the rack and sit in the lounge”.
“When this film finishes I want people to tidy the lounge and go to
their rooms”.
5. Tone Setting
Tone setting is directly to do with staff image. The image
and attitudes displayed by staff have a major effect on the
attitudes displayed by children and the prevailing atmosphere of the
House.
A graphic example could be seen at bedtime and pre-bedtime when it
is necessary to settle and calm the House. Noisy or boisterous
behaviour or horseplay by staff with children would set an
inappropriate tone — a tone which might be better applied during
early morning call. Manners, the tone of voice and mode of
addressing children, demeanour of staff, vitality etc., can all be
consciously employed to directly affect the tone of the House, and
resultant behaviour and demeanour of the children.
6.Individual Instruction
While there are many indirect techniques of child
management inevitably there is the need for direct individual child
instruction. This will be most noticeable at times of individual
unacceptable behaviour when children must be told directly TO STOP.
Staff should not shirk the responsibility of this direct
intervention nor should staff see this as the only available
technique through which they establish water-tight authority.
7. Adult Intervention
The ‘extreme’ nature of this program's intake often means
that children have been through a succession of placements. Four to
eight placements is usual. Many children will have been through the
same establishments at different times. Some will have been in the
same establishments at the same time. This can result in the arrival
of an established ‘culture’ among children based on their previous
experiences. Many children, after a residential career, are lost in
the expectations of peers. It is essential to ‘break them out’ of
such expectations and role conformity.
Adult intervention is necessary for a positive,
stable and ‘secure’ culture in a house such as this. The often
bizarre, impulsive, frightened and aggressive intake can produce a
negative, unstable, unsafe culture rooted in bullying, thuggery,
rudeness, madness and fear. It is essential that staff intervene
when they see the emergence of such negative influences. This
interference can be achieved by any of the range of management
techniques described in this section as seems appropriate to
prevailing circumstances. However direct
statements/instruction/action observable by children (often victims)
can be the best strategy for overall house stability.
An essential aspect of adult intervention is to
be practically aware, through file information, when children
have had previous contact and to sense when the resultant ‘culture’
occurs and to interrupt the ‘culture’. This
intervention/interruption can be achieved by practical methods:
(a) Manipulating meal time seating;
(b) Keeping such children separate by bed plan;
(c) Manipulating seating in group meetings;
(d) Manipulating seating for T.V.
Manipulating: “You sit there — You sit there”.
It is not essential to give reasons but often
the simple explanation based on the above and the need to assess the
individual make sense to children. While there is often verbal and
initial resistance to such interference (often based on maintaining
role image for peers, since that is the known ‘safety’ factor) most
children are relieved by the break in established
‘culture’/behaviour pattern.
A final area of adult intervention concerns
noise level and excitement. Our type of intake will often thrive
on and seek a chaotic environment and be resistant to or incapable
of ordered thought and daily living. Noise and extremes of
excitement level can be symptomatic of such children. It is
important therefore that staff limit noise level and directly break
up in activity of children who are getting over-excited. The noise
level of radio, tapes and T.V., is included here.
8. Early Intervention
Early intervention by staff in managing children’s
behaviour is often necessary. While it is possible to allow
unacceptable behaviour or squabbling/fighting to run their course
within boundaries protected by staff, early intervention in
situations can avoid the escalation of behaviour into a serious
incident category. Early intervention avoids:
(a) Escalation in intensity of behaviour;
(b) Additional members of the group participating in the behaviour;
(c) Deterioration in house atmosphere;
(d) The need for heavier management techniques.
Early intervention is particularly appropriate
where children’s behaviour patterns are well known/established and
where escalation is inevitable. Many of the range of management
techniques are suitable.
9. Adult Protection
There are occasions when children are engaged in activities
with other children or staff or merely sitting on their own when
other children harrass them. Adults should protect the boundaries of
such activity by direct intervention.
10. Diversion
Diversion is a child management technique which can be used
to break down boredom, suspect pairings or groups, excitement etc.
It is not necessary for children to observe or understand what is
happening. Diversion can be employed across the spectrum of daily
living. Diversion tactics include engaging in conversation,
introducing newspaper articles, or an activity or asking for help
with some chore.
11. Confronting — Not Confrontations
‘Confrontations’ are an inevitable corollary of living with
disordered children. ‘Confrontations’ tend to be explosive with
physical or verbal outbursts, they arise when child management
techniques have not been employed, or when they have failed.
Confrontations are not always avoidable and staff should not be
personally over concerned when they do occur.
Confronting, though not ‘Confrontation’ is a
child management technique. Confronting, simply put, is
describing/detailing to the child his/her behaviour, and where
necessary the effect of that behaviour on other people. Confronting
children with their behaviour does not mean a heated argument;
neither is it personal attack on the child. Ideally confronting
children with their behaviour should be a calm descriptive exercise
which can be used with individuals or in groups. It can be used
after behaviour has been observed, or in an analysis of a current
situation. When children realise that they are not being ‘picked on’
or blindly criticised they can be very receptive to this form of
management, which though establishing control, reduces conflict.
12. Counselling
“Counselling” appears in social work as a term which covers
many themes from a cosy chat to psychotherapy. Counselling in
this program involves practical discussion of behaviour and difficulties
presented by individual children. It is likely to be a response to:
(a) Adjustment to placement here.
(b) Questions asked about future placement;
(c) Implications of past behaviour for future;
(d) Aspects of present behaviour and their effects;
(e) Avoiding confrontations;
(f) Ways of resolving confrontations;
(g) Preparation for future placement;
(h) Adjusting child to management techniques;
(i) Aiding child’s recognition of patterns of behaviour.
The skills of counselling in this context are
mechanical and deliberately simplistic in nature. Lengthy, involved
discussions are likely to do little other than confuse the children.
However, if opportunity arises, listening to the children is likely
to help them begin to analyse their own history and problems. The
elements of such basic counselling would include:
(a) This aspect of your behaviour in this
circumstance leads to this outcome.
(b) This aspect of your behaviour taken from this situation will
lead to this outcome.
Counselling often involves asking questions to
try to establish the factors which affect the stability or
circumstances of the child.
13. Isolating Out/Cooling Off
There are many “heat of the moment” situations between
children, or with individual children which necessitate their being
separated from each other or from the group. This isolating
out action is to be used to give children a chance to ‘cool off’ and
to regain their self control. This action should not be confused
with a longer term additional measure of control nor would it
automatically constitute or be followed by a sanction. In many
instances the ideal end result is an early return to the group.
Isolating out is best used with follow-up counselling before a child
is restored to the group. Situations where isolating out might be
appropriate are:
(a) After a physical confrontation between
children;
(b) After a child’s refusal to follow an instruction or conform to
other child management technique;
(c) When child is wanting to opt out of activities or education;
(d) When a child has been particularly boisterous and seems unable
to self control.
14. Use of Humour
Humour and general cheerfulness can have a markedly
positive effect on individual children and groups. Care should be
taken to use humour at appropriate times, however. Humour can short
circuit a limit setting action by another staff distracting from the
focus of attention on that staff, or desired tone of house at
specific times.
Inappropriate humour in terms of content should
also be guarded against. Lewd jokes or jokes with an overt sexual or
swearing content are not helpful to tone setting. Resist the
temptation to be a ‘good bloke’ through such humour. Do not ridicule
children.
15. Daily Living Routines
Daily living routines are well established here. They
should remain so. While the routines are inevitably institutional in
nature normality within routine rather than forced routine should be
worked for. Smooth running daily routines bring order to the day and
predictability to children’s lives. The relevant routine sheets
should be adhered to.
16. Use of Ears and Eyes (Awareness)
A major aid to child management is simply staff keeping
their ears and eyes open. It is possible to heighten hearing and
observation skills and when children realise that staff have high
awareness ability much unacceptable behaviour can be prevented.
Staff awareness is a key skill and one which the new or experienced
staff should constantly work at. The inexperienced staff may lack
confidence in pure child management techniques but he/she has eyes
and ears which can provide information for more experienced staff to
work with.
Our staff should liken their work
to driving a car. It is very simple to drive in top gear very fast
on the motorway. There is seemingly little danger in driving through
town at 39 m.p.h. The good driver, however, is always
looking ahead and preparing for the unexpected, but predictable
hazards which experience teaches can arise. An
alertness to the likely unexpected always allows for avoiding
action.