Abstract
Much like a biological culture grown in a scientist’s Petri dish, global
concepts of culture have grown to include over one hundred and sixty
definitions (Australian Human Rights & Equal Opportunity Commission, 1998).
Many of these definitions suggest that there is a form of cultural mitosis
that allows a system of beliefs, values, assumptions, sentiments and
perspectives to be reproduced, unchanged, in a group of people over several
generations. This might have been true at some point in time, but "the
compression of the world and the intensification of consciousness of the
world as a whole" (Robertson, 1992, p.8) has blurred group boundaries and
created a new level of awareness that is simultaneously liberating and
frightening. This compression, also known as globalization, has "economic
roots and political consequences" (Rothkop, 1997) that are nurtured and
shaped by culture. This essay takes a personal close-up cultural snapshot
and projects it onto the cultural landscape to find relevance and
connectivity between the personal and the global, the immediate and the
overall.
Memories
The stevedores on the dock in Port of Spain, Trinidad talked and moved with
a rhythm that was both strange and fascinating to my 15-year-old eyes. Trinidad
was my family’s third country of residence in my lifetime, and my senses
anxiously panned the port for some hint of familiarity, but I found none. At
that moment, nothing about this island nation was as I’d expected; the mountains
seemed unfriendly, the smells were indistinct, and the rhythm of language and
movement seemed strained. I was born in Jamaica of Jamaican parents, and had
lived throughout Latin America since the age of four. According to historical
and geographical accounts, Trinidad and Jamaica shared many similarities because
of British and Spanish colonization. It was after all, an English-speaking
island populated by groups of people who had shared many of the same life
experiences. Still, nothing my parents had passed on to me prepared me for the
strange rhythm. The crushing sense of alienation as we docked in Port of Spain
did not restrain parental expectations that we "grow where we’re planted". My
parents must have based this edict on Hall’s observation that "if one wanted to
fit in, or not appear too conspicuous, it was helpful to begin to move to the
local rhythm and conform to the local beat" (Hall, 1989, p.79). And conform we
did, without apology, and without fear of betraying our ‘group’ we adopted the
rhythmic speech and tucked our other language neatly into diaries and sibling
conspiracies.
Sociologist Ruth Useem coined the term "Third
Culture Kids" (TCKs) (Kidd, 2002) to describe children in families who
reside outside their passport country for extended periods of time. Dr. Useem’s
longitudinal research suggests that these children integrate elements of those
cultures where they live with their own birth culture into a third, different
and distinct culture (Eakin, 1998; Useem, 1999). Because TCKs have developed a
unique culture of their own that incorporates elements of varied cultures, they
often feel more at home with other TCKs, with no regard for nationality.
For all of my childhood and adolescence I experienced life as a TCK without ever
labeling or understanding the intensity of the experience. My friends were
mostly other TCKs, and we nurtured our adolescent friendship with an endless
stream of letters and cards.
Many years and countries after Trinidad, my
‘differentness’ invariably raised the question: "Where are you from?" which
frequently elicited: "Where do you think I’m from?" Or the more straightforward:
"I’m from many places". I indeed felt in sync with many places and
simultaneously no singular allegiance to any of them. Sociologists might have
ascribed my lack of connectivity to my own unarticulated sense of identity. The
truth was that I was afflicted with cultural marginality – "an experience
typical of global nomads and others (such as TCKs) who have been molded by
exposure to two or more cultural traditions" (Schaetti). Cultural marginality,
like any intense experience, has the potential to have either good or bad
outcomes, depending on how it is resolved. For most global nomads or TCKs,
resolution is usually jump started by their return ‘home’. At that time (usually
late adolescence or young adulthood) resolution often takes one of two paths –
encapsulated or constructive (Bennett, 1993). The encapsulated path is a less
desirable resolution that leaves the individual with overwhelming feelings of
failed authenticity, alienation and powerlessness (Bennett, p.115). Feelings of
isolation and a pervasive sense of being misunderstood often dominate the psyche
of the encapsulated culturally marginal individual. By contrast, the
constructive resolution to cultural marginality leads to a resilient well
developed sense of identity that "forms clear boundaries in the face of multiple
cultural perspectives" (Bennett, p.118). While national identity continues to be
relatively insignificant, constructively resolved culturally marginal
individuals are able to use their intercultural skills and adjustment skills to
further personal and professional goals (Schaetti).
Take me Home, To the Place I Belong…
My return to my passport country as a young adult brought with it lingering
discomfort related to not belonging, the sense of not fitting in, the
inexplicable detachment that didn’t measure up to expectations of coming ‘home’.
More than ever before I felt dislocated and the usual tools of cultural
reconciliation were evasive. My search for synthesis led me to migrate to
Canada, a country whose acceptance of cultural ambiguity and people-centered (as
opposed to nationality-centered) immigration policies seemed to invite
resolution. It was there, with introspective anonymity that my own constructive
resolution began. While I struggled with self-actualization, south of the
border, the plight of hundreds of TCKs had finally attracted the attention of
the U.S. diplomatic community through a report from the Association of American
Foreign Service Women. From this report, the Family Liaison Office under the
Department of State was formed to support and study the TCK phenomenon (Eakin
1999, p.5). These studies have pioneered new insight, descriptive terminology
and support (Kidd, 2002) for us cultural mutants.
Constructively resolved marginality helped me
to redirect my energies into working with children, particularly immigrant
children who by default are left to struggle with being culturally marginal. But
does resolution inhibit wanderlust? Can TCKs ever accept the cultural ties that
bind? To date, there’s no research-based evidence to prove or disprove either
question, leaving nationalistic devotees with fears of culturally diluted
Americans. However, personal accounts (Schaetti) and my own experience suggest
that global nomads need to feel fulfilled in their multicultural skins, and
"cannot be contained within a single identity" (Schaetti). For us, it appears
"better to acknowledge that nationality is only an overlay to the international
experience" (Schaetti). Unfortunately, recent fears powered by global acts of
violence have led many people unaffected by cultural marginality to believe
"that ‘foreign’ is a synonym for ‘danger’" (Rothkop, 1997), and any attempt to
shrink from nationalistic ideals is seen as an even greater indication of
danger.
Heating Up the Melting Pot
Most of the existing research focuses on TCKs returning to the United
States, a country long known as a country of immigrants. The American culture
has even been conceptualized as a ‘melting pot’ of cultures, coalesced to form a
single strong culture where the sum was more significant than the parts. If
nothing, this conceptualization bespeaks inclusion, and implies that all
cultures contribute to American largesse. In practice, this concept could have
powerful and enduring value in its ability to enable the smallest unit of the
whole, in its ability to seduce ex-patriots ‘home’. Unfortunately, the melting
pot has for the most part remained a cultural construct that is difficult to
enact, and TCKs continue to reject their passport country: "Physically, I am
here. But everything that belongs to me, everything that defines me, is on the
other side of the ocean where I left my friends" (Eakin, 1999, p. 12). I’m
forced to wonder if the temperature of the melting pot were only slightly
different, if it would not create a path home for TCKs; a path that embraces and
values their nomadic core, a path that fostered their multicultural identities
as synonymous with America. After all, the main difference between TCKs and non-TCKs
is that non-TCKs have "roots that are strong and understood. While they may
leave these roots, the sense of place, of where they are from is strong and
grows stronger as the years pass" (Eakin, p.19). On the other, hand, " TCKs
roots, are determined by people, not place" (Eakin, p.19).
Conclusion
Many definitions of culture call for interactions among people – behavior,
tradition, and customs. It would therefore seem important to foster the
strengths and skills of the global nomad or TCK and "encourage or facilitate the
constructive experience of cultural marginality" (Schaetti). There is amazing
power to be harnessed in the TCKs’ ability to be reconciled to each new culture
and embrace their multiplicity without fear, a truly global skill. After all, is
this not the conceptualized Melting Pot?
References
Bennett, J. "Cultural Marginality: Identity Issues in Intercultural
Training." Education for The Intercultural Experience. E. Michael Paige, Ed.,
Maine, Intercultural Press
Eakin, K. (1999). "According To My Passport,
I’m Coming Home". Washington D.C., FLO, GPO.
Hall, E. T. (1989). "Beyond Culture".
New York: Random House, Inc.
Kidd, J. (2000). "Third Culture Kids:
Returning to their Passport Country". Retrieved June 30, 2004
Robertson, R. (1992) "Globalization: Social
Theory and Global Culture". London: Sage
Rothkop, D. "In Praise of Cultural Imperialism?
Effects of Globalization on Culture". Global Policy Forum. June 22, 1997
Schaetti, B. "Phoenix Rising: A question of
Cultural Identity". Downloaded on 3/2/2005 From